Naples to Cease Water Fluoridation After 74 Years

By Lee Sells Naples, Fast!

In a significant policy shift, the Naples City Council has voted to discontinue the fluoridation of the city's public water supply, a practice maintained for the past 74 years. The decision, reached on December 4, 2024, passed with a narrow 4-3 vote, with council members Ray Christman, Linda Penniman, and Beth Petrunoff dissenting.

WUSF

Background on Fluoridation

Fluoridation involves adding fluoride to public drinking water to prevent tooth decay, a measure endorsed by numerous health organizations, including the American Dental Association (ADA) and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Proponents argue that it is a cost-effective public health intervention that benefits all community members, particularly those without access to regular dental care.

Local and Statewide Trends

Naples' decision aligns with a broader trend in the region. In February 2024, Collier County commissioners unanimously voted to cease water fluoridation after 39 years, citing health concerns and public demand.

NBC 2

Additionally, the cities of Marco Island and Everglades City do not fluoridate their water supplies.

The debate over water fluoridation has intensified following recent recommendations from Florida's Surgeon General, Joseph Ladapo, who advised against adding fluoride to public drinking water. This stance contrasts with positions held by national health authorities, leading to varied responses from local governments across the state.

WUSF

Public Response and Council Deliberations

The council's decision followed extensive public commentary, with citizens and health professionals presenting arguments both for and against fluoridation. Supporters emphasized fluoride's role in preventing dental decay and promoting oral health equity. Dr. Johnny Johnson, president of the American Fluoridation Society, noted that fluoridated water is the most cost-effective way to deliver fluoride to all community members, benefiting everyone regardless of income or access to dental care.

WUSF

Opponents raised concerns about potential health risks, referencing studies suggesting links between fluoride exposure and adverse health outcomes. These concerns have been echoed in other municipalities, contributing to a reevaluation of fluoridation policies.

Implementation and Future Considerations

The cessation of water fluoridation in Naples is scheduled to take effect by January 1, 2025, or earlier if feasible. As the city transitions away from this long-standing public health measure, residents may need to seek alternative sources of fluoride, such as toothpaste or dietary supplements, to maintain dental health.

This policy change reflects a growing trend of communities reassessing the benefits and risks associated with water fluoridation, balancing public health objectives with emerging scientific evidence and public opinion.

Fluoride in Drinking Water: Safety and Public Health Perspectives

Food & Wine

Fluoride in Drinking Water Is Actually Quite Safe - Here's What to Know

7 days ago